Breaking Through the Fee Barrier: How Top Financial Advisors Create Equitable Client Relationships

Introduction

According to a recent study by Cerulli Associates, only 28% of financial advisors charge planning fees, despite 72% of clients expressing willingness to pay for objective financial advice. This disconnect reveals an opportunity many advisors are missing—the chance to create more equitable, trust-based client relationships while simultaneously building a more sustainable practice model.

If you're an established financial advisor who's been struggling with the "free advice dilemma," you're not alone. Many advisors provide comprehensive financial planning services at no cost, hoping to eventually convert prospects into asset management or insurance clients. Yet this approach often creates an unspoken tension: clients may question whether recommendations truly serve their best interests or simply generate advisor compensation.

In this article, we'll explore how top-performing advisors have broken through this barrier to create fee-based planning practices that foster deeper client trust, provide more comprehensive service, and build more sustainable business models—all without sacrificing revenue or growth potential.

‍

Why Most Advisors Hesitate to Charge Planning Fees

The Internal Mindset Barrier

For many advisors, the biggest obstacle to implementing a fee-based planning model isn't client resistance—it's their own hesitation. As Abby Spaulding, owner of Continuum Planning Partners, describes her initial experience: "Most of it was the mind shift to me of that imposter syndrome of like, can I do this? Will people pay a fee? And is this fee reasonable?"

This psychological barrier typically manifests in several common concerns:

1. Fear that clients won't value planning enough to pay for it
2. Uncertainty about appropriate fee structures
3. Worry about losing prospects to "free" competitors
4. Concern about managing client expectations when charging fees

The Misconception of Client Resistance

Contrary to what many advisors believe, research indicates clients are increasingly seeking advisors who provide objective advice without product conflicts. In fact, according to a 2023 Vanguard study, 68% of affluent investors prefer fee-based advisors specifically because they perceive the advice as more trustworthy.

Spaulding confirms this market reality: "I have found that the market is actually pretty thirsty for advice that people can pay for. I get what we call phantom referrals, meaning I didn't ask for them, they called into our office all the time saying, I hear you are an advisor that I can pay for advice with."

‍

4 Proven Strategies for Transitioning to Fee-Based Planning

1. Reframe Your Value Proposition Around Equitable Relationships

Top-performing advisors don't apologize for charging planning fees—they position it as the foundation of an equitable relationship that benefits clients.

Implementation Steps:

• Clearly articulate how fee-based planning creates aligned interests
• Explain how this model allows for more objective recommendations
• Demonstrate how decoupling planning from implementation removes inherent conflicts

Real-World Example: Spaulding explains to prospects: "When you do financial planning that is paid for advice, it puts us in an equitable standing with our clients. And that equitable standing means that you've paid for advice and I am giving you my best advice."

She further contrasts this with the traditional model: "Most advisors do wealth management and they give free financial planning. And we really believe that those two things need to be decoupled... if all of my compensation is tied to managing your money, even the best advisors are disincentivized from telling you to pay off debt."

"I had somewhat of an epiphany of like, I actually know way more than all of my clients and they need what I have more than I need their money."
_{- Abby Spaulding}

‍

2. Adopt the "Architect/Contractor" Model

Successful fee-based planners often use clear metaphors to distinguish between their planning and implementation roles.

Implementation Steps:

• Develop a simple, clear explanation of the planning relationship
• Create distinct service agreements for planning versus implementation
• Establish clear boundaries between these services

Real-World Example: "On the financial planning relationship, clients pay us to be their architect. We come in and build those blueprints. And as your life changes, we want to be on site to make those modifications," explains Spaulding. "If you want us to implement on those plans, I can switch hats and be your contractor. We can manage the money. We can implement on the insurance."

This clear delineation helps clients understand they're paying for expertise and objective guidance, not just product implementation.

3. Implement an Annual Renewal Model

Rather than positioning planning as a one-time service, top advisors create ongoing relationships with regular renewals.

Implementation Steps:

• Structure planning engagements as annual agreements
• Create a clear process for annual plan reviews
• Communicate the value of ongoing advice, not just implementation

Real-World Example: Spaulding tells clients: "The beauty of my industry and job is that financial planning doesn't end. We don't put it in a drawer and say, I'm so glad we checked that box and it's over. So we want to do a financial plan for our clients in perpetuity."

She frames this agreement upfront: "You are paying me for a financial plan and next year you will pay me again and the following year you will pay me again and indefinitely."

A colleague of hers puts it even more succinctly: "We don't do one 25-year plan, we do 25 one-year plans."

4. Take a Progressive Approach to Fee Implementation

Many successful advisors acknowledge that transitioning to fee-based planning often follows a "crawl, walk, run" progression.

Implementation Steps:

• Start with modest fees to build confidence
• Gradually increase fees as you refine your process and deliverables
• Establish minimum fees based on your business model and overhead
• Institute clear renewal structures

Real-World Example: According to Spaulding: "We all undercharge in the beginning because you're scared as hell and you don't know how to charge. You don't know what your hourly rate should be. You're trying to get your systems built up."

This progression allows advisors to gain confidence in their fee structure while refining their planning process and deliverables. Over time, as the value becomes clear, advisors can establish appropriate minimums and renewal structures.

‍

Advanced Strategies for Established Practices

Managing Existing Relationships

For advisors with established client bases, the transition to fee-based planning requires thoughtful client communication. Top performers recommend:

1. Don't force immediate changes - Allow existing clients to transition on their timeline
2. Lead with value - Demonstrate enhanced planning before discussing fees
3. Provide implementation options - Allow clients to maintain existing relationships

Spaulding takes a particularly effective approach with clients who have existing advisors: "What I normally tell people who have an existing wealth advisor is don't fire them. They probably candidly have done a good job. I'm going to audit their account and I'll tell you what's going well and what's what I would do differently."

She continues with confidence: "By year three you will fire them because we will provide so much more service and so much more output you will not like managing us both. But you'll make that decision."

Building a Scalable Fee-Based Practice

The highest-performing fee-based planners don't just charge for planning—they build systematic businesses around this model. Key elements include:

1. Working on the business - Setting aside dedicated time for business planning
2. Complementary partnerships - Finding partners with complementary skills
3. Service model development - Creating systematic client service experiences
4. Proactive planning - Anticipating market and client needs

In Spaulding's words: "I have found that working and setting aside time to work on the business, not just in the business, is invaluable time. The more we have been able to step back and look at and build a service model and build a one year, two year, three year, five year, 10 year, case model for our client services... has been an invaluable part."

‍

The Path Forward: Transforming Your Practice

Implementing a fee-based planning model doesn't happen overnight, but advisors who make this transition consistently report several key benefits:

1. Increased client trust - When clients pay directly for advice, they place greater value on it
2. More holistic advice - Advisors can recommend debt paydown, charitable giving, or other non-AUM strategies without compensation conflicts
3. Consistent revenue - Planning fees provide predictable income separate from market fluctuations
4. Expanded client base - Fee-based planning allows advisors to work with clients who have few investable assets but need significant planning help, such as business owners

‍

Your Next Step

Ready to explore how a fee-based planning model might work in your practice? We've created a comprehensive Fee-Based Planning Transition Kit that includes:

• Fee structure templates and calculators
• Client communication scripts
• Sample planning agreements
• Implementation timeline templates
• Case studies of successful transitions

Download Your Fee-Based Planning Transition Kit

‍

‍

Real World examples are for illustrative purposes only, not everyone will experience the same results.

Financial plan recommendations can be implemented with the advisor of your choosing.

Implementation of specific products or services may result in commissions or fees outside of the financial planning fee. Securities, Investment Advisory and Financial Planning Services offered through qualified registered representatives of MML Investors Services, LLC, Member SIPC.

Axiom Planning Resources is not a subsidiary or affiliate of MML Investors Services, LLC, or its affiliated companies. 10 Cadillac Drive, Suite 300, Brentwood, TN 37027 (615) 309-6300.

‍